What might the Milburn Report mean for claimants and devolved policy makers in Scotland?
By Hayley Bennett,
On 17.11.26 former Labour Health Secretary Alan Milburn published a UK government supported report, proposed the overhaul of social security and employment policies for young people as a way to address rising youth unemployment and economic inactivity across the UK. There are implications across the UK government of this new settlement of rights, responsibilities, and employment support for young people.
For claimants and policymakers in Scotland, social security and employment support are complex policy areas. There are multiple agencies involved, shared policy competencies between Westminster and Holyrood, and spatial inequalities affecting labour market participation. Even without intricate multi-level governance arrangements, the reasons why young people may be in need of support are varied, often reflecting structural economic conditions, as well as individual issues (for example related to health, family circumstances, and more).
Various relevant policies and services are devolved competencies in Scotland (such as education, careers, and skills); however, the UK government (via the Department for Work and Pensions) retains responsibility for the main working age benefit (Universal Credit, UC), its digital implementation infrastructure, plus the GB wide Jobcentre Plus network. As such the Milburn report - which recommends substantial changes to benefits including UC (there are 600,000 recipients in Scotland) and a plethora of employment support initiatives for young people – will either have direct implications for claimants living in Scotland or create ripples into devolved policy areas. Two key aspects to consider:
- Substantial changes to social security payments for young people: Milburn recommends a new ‘Youth Allowance’ to replace UC for young claimants entirely, including the existing health-related element. This would be paid at the same level as the basic rate (approx., £78 per week), and young people would no longer qualify for the Work Capability Assessment needed to claim the health top-up in UC (worth between £200 and £400). The report argues that, “preserving the present architecture and adding new programmes around it would leave too many of the existing fault lines intact” in the social security system. However, a new and separate benefit is a particularly bold suggestion, and one that would take a lot of investment in implementation mechanisms to achieve. There isn’t room for the detail in this blog, but there are numerous aspects to consider including the potential costs associated in design and delivery.
If the new Youth Allowance becomes a reality, the proposal is for an accompanying “devolved health component” meaning a cash payment for some young people with health-related costs. This is a noteworthy proposition as it raises questions about exactly who would design and administer this new component and how it might be expected to be implemented by subnational actors in England alongside responsibilities for health and economic development. For Scotland it will need to be arranged differently because the devolution and localisation agenda here is a substantially different construction than what is developing in England. Multi-level benefit administration is already very difficult for claimants to manage effectively (e.g. due to increased administrative burdens). Policy implementation determines effectiveness and fragmented implementation can intensify inequalities. Plus, devolving DWP services is complicated. As such, the advantages of this approach are not clear. Perhaps being a little cynical, introducing a new benefit could enable UK government to reassess current claimants under 25 (rather than remove existing payments and trigger tribunals/appeals) to reduce welfare spending. It could also, if devolved to subnational organisations, decouple basic Youth Allowance payment from the additional support components for health issues, thus creating a separate (and possibly more discretionary) system run by non-DWP organisations.
One of the notable recommendations by Milburn is to limit who can access Personal Independence Payments (PiP), a benefit supporting people (both in and out of work with extra costs due to health conditions). PiP is already devolved in Scotland, which the Scottish Government reworked to become the Adult Disability Payment (ADP) in 2022. On the face of it, changes to entitlements and eligibilities to PiP (in England, Wales and NI), may not affect claimants of ADP in Scotland. However, as a devolved benefit, it is subject to the equivalence principle meaning that changes to PiP could alter the financial resources that underpin ADP. In this case, it would mean Scottish policymakers having to make a difficult decision about whether to also alter entitlements and eligibilities.
- Employment support for young people: One outcome of the Smith Commission back in 2014 was for Scotland to gain increased policy responsibilities and power over some aspects of employment support. At the time, this in effect meant devolving the Scottish element of the UK-wide Work Programme, taking it out of the Department for Work and Pensions (UK government service) and moving to the Scottish Government. The UK wide Work Programme (2011-2017) was a multi-million-pound welfare-to-work scheme, administered via competitively tendered ‘contract package areas’ across the UK, various private and third sector organisations operated under a payments-by-result model to move people into work. The devolution ‘ask’ back in 2014 was relatively simple; instead of the DWP procuring Work Programme services for (non-public) delivery organisations to operate across Scotland, the Scottish Government took responsibility using an equivalent allocated financial amount. Vowing to run things differently, the Scottish Government created the Fair Start Scotland scheme (2018-2024) using different procurement approaches and incorporating service changes such as removing mandatory participation for claimants.
In 2026 the Milburn report is playing out in a very different governance context for employment support. As noted Scotland has held some powers over employment support for over ten years (although arguably underutilised), and the new(ish) UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham has spent his first five months launching a commitment to ‘Rewiring the State’ encouraging and committing to substantial regional and local infrastructural reforms across England (and possibly elsewhere), including for employment support and economic growth at the local level. Thus, the equivalence principle and policy opportunity are less simple than in 2014. Furthermore, if new youth employment support initiatives are to be delivered locally in England for example via additional funding to Strategic Authorities, the Scottish Government may find itself able to avail of additional resources that it could choose to allocate to improving its own employability services in Scotland. However, if the UK government decide to support young people via the existing Jobcentre Plus network in Scotland (which is a reserved service operating across Britain, including in Scotland) new services would fall within the DWP’s remit (as job centre, work coaches, and Universal Credit interface currently do), rather than within Scottish Government responsibilities.
The Milburn report potentially offers significant disruption to the status quo, and raises a lot of questions about powers, accountability, limitations for policy divergence, and whether there’s increased possibility for a new DWP devolution deal in Scotland. However, Milburn recommends that his underlying principles (a clear guarantee, accountable local ownership, joined-up support, better use of data and continuing responsibility for the transition into work) will be applied across the UK. As such, Scottish policymakers and researchers need to engage with the finer details and critically consider various implementation approaches.
---
Dr Hayley Bennett is a Senior Lecturer in Social Policy and Co-Director of the Centre on Constitutional Change, University of Edinburgh. She is also co-investigator and Scotland Country Lead for the Safety Nets project(2024-2028), exploring devolved and local social security across the UK.