We Are Still a Long Way from Federalism

Michaell Keating discusses how we are still a long way from federalism but closer to a constitutional clash as further Brexit legislation looms. This article appeard in The Herald.

The devolution settlements of 1999 were a way of squaring a circle. On the one hand, they gave the non-English parts of the United Kingdom elected assemblies in recognition of their distinct national identities. On the other hand, they preserved the principle of the absolute sovereignty and supremacy of Westminster. The UK ceased to be a unitary state but did not become a federation in which the powers of both levels would be constrained by law. Theoretically, Westminster could still legislate on all matters.

Instead, devolved powers were protected by the Sewel convention, that Westminster would not normally legislate in devolved matters without the consent of the relevant legislature. This was extended in practice to changes in the competences of the devolved bodies.

Conventions are understandings about how our political institutions work. They are one of the foundations of our largely unwritten constitution. Yet there is no legal mechanism to enforce them. Instead, when conventions are flouted, there is a constitutional crisis as happened in 1909 when the House of Lords refused to pass the budget; in that case the convention was put in legislative form as the Parliament Act.

Following the 2014 independence referendum, all parties agreed to give the Scottish Parliament stronger constitutional guarantees in statutory form. The 2016 Scotland Act declared that the Parliament was a permanent part of the constitution and included the Sewel convention.

The Supreme Court judgment was the first test. The Court has ruled that, as Brexit is not just foreign policy but affects domestic policy, it requires parliamentary approval. It also recognizes that it affects devolved matters. It has, however, rejected the conclusion that a legislative consent motion is needed. It might have made this ruling on the narrow grounds that Brexit is not a ‘normal’situation. Instead, it has ruled that Sewel is not legally enforceable at all.  It is not surprising that the courts have declared that they are not competent to enforce the convention, but it does leave a gap in our constitution. There is no legal provision to protect the powers of devolved institutions and Westminster reigns supreme. We are still a long way from federalism but closer to a constitutional clash as further Brexit legislation looms.

 

Comments policy

All comments posted on the site via Disqus are automatically published. Additionally comments are sent to moderators for checking and removal if necessary. We encourage open debate and real time commenting on the website. The Centre on Constitutional Change cannot be held responsible for any content posted by users. Any complaints about comments on the site should be sent to info@centreonconstitutionalchange.ac.uk

Michael Keating's picture
post by Michael Keating
University of Aberdeen
25th January 2017
Filed under:

Latest blogs

  • 16th October 2018

    Bavaria’s long-dominant party, the conservative Christian Social Union (CSU), has reached its worst election result in 60 years. As well as causing a headache for Angela Merkel, argues Patrick Utz, this political earthquake reveals Bavaria’s predicament between regionalism and populism,.

  • 15th October 2018

    As the buildup to the EU Council meeting reaches fever pitch, Richard Parry explains that deals at dawn may work in Brussels but they don't always play to the home crowd.

  • 13th October 2018

    Theresa May’s efforts to keep her DUP allies onside may, suggests Prof Nicola McEwen, end up easing Nicola Sturgeon’s path to independence following any subsequent referendum on the subject.

  • 12th October 2018

    The Commission on Justice in Wales, chaired by Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, will further clarify the legal and political identity of Wales within the UK constitution. Doing so, explains Prof Dan Wincott, will also bring clarity to the enduring significance of other territorial legal jurisdictions.

  • 11th October 2018

    The Brexit and Environment network has spent the last year researching the implications of Brexit for environmental policy, with a particular focus on the devolved nations, which are all too often overlooked in these debates. They have developed three reports that detail their findings from meetings with stakeholders in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, and they bring together insights from these in an overarching UK report. In this blog post, they summarise their key findings and recommendations.

Read More Posts