Class divisions and the Scottish Referendum

The Scottish Independence referendum campaign has focused heavily on the economic impacts of independence –whether the No campaign’s claims of a “UK dividend” or the Yes campaign’s promise of an economic renaissance for a newly independent Scotland. But how do voters’ own economic situations affect their preferences for independence?

The graph below shows the level of support for independence among voters in different social classes (coded based on respondents’ current or most recent occupation). Support for independence is highest among supervisors, small business owners and routine workers (e.g. assembly line workers, waiters and cleaners), with intermediate workers (e.g. secretaries and computer operators) and senior managers showing the lowest support for independence.


This divide over the referendum is somewhat different to the main class divides in British politics. For instance, below is the proportion of voters in each class who intend to vote for Labour (across the whole of the UK). In this case, there is a clear gradient in support from the highest social groups to the lowest (with the exception of small employers). Thus, while voters in the Scottish referendum are divided by class, they aren’t falling along the same working/middle class division that has traditionally structured party competition in the UK.


It’s not just class that’s dividing voters. Some of the largest differences in support for independence are between renters and home owners. On average, only 32% of freehold home owners support independence compared to nearly more than half of people who rent their property from a council or housing association. One possible explanation for these differences is the circulation of reports claiming that mortgages will become more expensive and house prices may fall if Scotland becomes independent.


Some of these economic differences in independence support can be explained by differences in political values. Economically left wing voters are far more likely to support independence than voters on the right. Economic values can explain much of the difference between home owners and renters as well as the difference between senior managers and routine workers. Other groups’ support, though, is harder to explain. Small business owners –often a conservative leaning group –are among the strongest supporters of independence (although a majority still oppose it).

Regardless of the eventual outcome of the referendum, these divisions could have a lasting impact on politics long after September in the patterns of support for the SNP.


Technical note: The first wave of the British Election Study was conducted between February and March 2014. Of the 4139 Scottish voters interviewed, 3615 reported how they intend to vote in the upcoming referendum. All of the analysis in this post focuses only on respondents who expressed a preference one way or the other.  Social class is only coded for around half the sample so the figures in that figure will change slightly once the full sample is coded.


Comments policy

All comments posted on the site via Disqus are automatically published. Additionally comments are sent to moderators for checking and removal if necessary. We encourage open debate and real time commenting on the website. The Centre on Constitutional Change cannot be held responsible for any content posted by users. Any complaints about comments on the site should be sent to

Jon Mellon's picture
post by Jon Mellon
Nuffield College at the University of Oxford
19th June 2014
Filed under:

Latest blogs

  • 12th February 2019

    CCC Fellow Professor Daniel Wincott of Cardiff University examines how Brexit processes have already reshaped territorial politics in the UK and changed its territorial constitution.

  • 7th February 2019

    The future of agriculture policy across the United Kingdom after Brexit is uncertain and risky, according to a new paper by Professor Michael Keating of the Centre on Constitutional Change. Reforms of the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy over recent years have shifted the emphasis from farming to the broader concept of rural policy. As member states have gained more discretion in applying policy, the nations of the UK have also diverged, according to local conditions and preferences.

  • 4th February 2019

    In our latest report for the "Repatriation of Competences: Implications for Devolution" project, Professor Nicola McEwen and Dr Alexandra Remond examine how, in the longer term, Brexit poses significant risks for the climate and energy ambitions of the devolved nations. These include the loss of European Structural and Investment Funds targeted at climate and low carbon energy policies, from which the devolved territories have benefited disproportionately. European Investment Bank loan funding, which has financed high risk renewables projects, especially in Scotland, may also no longer be as accessible, while future access to research and innovation funding remains uncertain. The removal of the EU policy framework, which has incentivised the low carbon ambitions of the devolved nations may also result in lost opportunities.

  • 1st February 2019

    The outcome of the various Commons votes this week left certain only that the Government would either secure an amended deal and put it to a meaningful vote on Wednesday 13 February, or in the overwhelmingly likely absence of this make a further statement that day and table another amendable motion for the following day, the Groundhog Day that may lead to a ‘St Valentine’s Day Massacre’ for one side or the other. Richard Parry assesses the further two-week pause in parliamentary action on Brexit

  • 24th January 2019

    Concerns about the implications of the Irish backstop for the integrity of the domestic Union contributed significantly to the scale of the 118-strong backbench rebellion that led to Theresa May’s Withdrawal Agreement being defeated last week, by the extraordinary margin of 432 to 202. What do the arguments made during the Commons debate tell us about the nature of the ‘unionism’ that prevails in the contemporary Conservative Party?

Read More Posts