Brexit Reflections - Who is the captain of the ship now?

Malcolm Harvey discusses issues around a referendum that was supposed to resolve the UK’s position in Europe but appears to have muddied it further.

A week might be a long time in politics, but a long weekend gave us enough headlines for a lifetime. So, what’s next?

At the moment, no one can really say with any certainty. The Leave campaign did not expect to win, and thus do not have a clear plan outlined for Brexit. The UK Government, similarly, had not made contingency plans. At any rate, a political vacuum exists in the UK in which the sands are constantly shifting. The Prime Minister’s resignation leaves him in a caretaker role, his authority temporary at best.  Across the House of Commons, the Opposition also lack leadership – and their chaotic attempts to topple Jeremy Corbyn emphasise in stark terms just how divided the party is. How ironic that the EU – an issue which for decades has divided the Conservatives – looks like it might be the catalyst for a permanent split in the Labour party.

In these chaotic circumstances, uncertainty reigns, and opportunities abound. 

The SNP appear to have grasped this opportunity with both hands. First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has underlined the lack of leadership at Westminster by acting swiftly and decisively in the days after the referendum vote. Removing Scotland from the EU against its clearly stated will would be “democratically unacceptable” she told the media in her post-referendum address, and that everything was “on the table” as options going forward, including a second independence referendum.

SNP MEP Alyn Smith was afforded a standing ovation in the European Parliament when he told MEPs “Scotland did not let you down… do not let Scotland down now”. In the Scottish Parliament, the First Minister sought and was granted the authority to negotiate with EU representatives on behalf of the parliament. As a result, she met with the President of the EU Commission Jean-Claude Juncker, the President of the European Parliament Martin Schulz, and several other representatives from various member states to present Scotland’s position. 

There have been no end of articles in the past week suggesting a variety of options for both Scotland and the UK as we progress through the negotiations which should lead to “Brexit”, and each option has advantages and disadvantages. One thing is clear though – in the past week, the Scottish Government and the Scottish Parliament have, for the first time, declared their intention to pursue a decidedly different foreign policy from Westminster. This is a significant development, and emphasises the profound differences that exist at the different levels of government.

A referendum that was supposed to resolve the UK’s position in Europe appears to have muddied it further, and created internal constitutional and party political leadership crises to boot. Whoever takes on the leadership of the UK will face two fundamental issues – how the UK will position itself internationally post-Brexit, and just how United that Kingdom will be.

Leaders lead – and Nicola Sturgeon has done just that. As Jeremy Corbyn and David Cameron have found out in the last week, a leader without followers is just a guy taking a walk.

Comments policy

All comments posted on the site via Disqus are automatically published. Additionally comments are sent to moderators for checking and removal if necessary. We encourage open debate and real time commenting on the website. The Centre on Constitutional Change cannot be held responsible for any content posted by users. Any complaints about comments on the site should be sent to info@centreonconstitutionalchange.ac.uk

Latest blogs

  • 19th October 2018

    Proposed revisions to the Basque Statute of Autonomy have revealed underlying tensions but the fault lines are not where an outside observer might assume they would be. They are fundamental and political and, explains Michael Keating, unlikely to be resolved by technocratic debate.

  • 16th October 2018

    Bavaria’s long-dominant party, the conservative Christian Social Union (CSU), has reached its worst election result in 60 years. As well as causing a headache for Angela Merkel, argues Patrick Utz, this political earthquake reveals Bavaria’s predicament between regionalism and populism,.

  • 15th October 2018

    As the buildup to the EU Council meeting reaches fever pitch, Richard Parry explains that deals at dawn may work in Brussels but they don't always play to the home crowd.

  • 13th October 2018

    Theresa May’s efforts to keep her DUP allies onside may, suggests Prof Nicola McEwen, end up easing Nicola Sturgeon’s path to independence following any subsequent referendum on the subject.

  • 12th October 2018

    The Commission on Justice in Wales, chaired by Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, will further clarify the legal and political identity of Wales within the UK constitution. Doing so, explains Prof Dan Wincott, will also bring clarity to the enduring significance of other territorial legal jurisdictions.

Read More Posts